Victims
with Disabilities
The Bureau of Justice Statistics (BJS), in response to the mandates
of Public Law 105-301, the Crime Victims with Disabilities Awareness
Act (CVDAA), is working to develop the capability to measure
crimes against people with disabilities. The Act requires the enhancement
of the National Crime Victimization Survey (NCVS) to collect these
data.
Since 2000, BJS has initiated several activities to lay the foundation
for developing such estimates. Consistent with the experience of
other Federal agencies, there are a number of issues that must
be addressed in order to design methodologies to meet the mandates
of the legislation, including developing a reliable set of questions
to identify people with developmental and other disabilities, and
developing procedures to accommodate, as necessary, interviews
with such people. BJS and the Census Bureau, which conducts NCVS
interviewing, consulted and worked with staff from a number of
Federal agencies to develop survey questions to identify people
with disabilities.
In July 2000, BJS added to the NCVS Crime Incident Report a test
of supplemental items designed to obtain information from victims
of crime on any health conditions, impairments or disabilities
affecting their everyday life. In fall 2001, BJS, together with
the Census Bureau, fielded a test among known persons with development
disabilities in California to further test questions related to
disability and to determine what types of interview techniques
work best with different types of populations with disabilities.
Based on the results of the tests, BJS and the Census Bureau developed
a revised set of questions to address problems that were identified.
The revised questions were implemented into the NCVS in January
2004, and will be evaluated to determine whether they obtain reliable
information. Once finalized, the questions will produce estimates
of the faction of victims who have disabilities. The survey will
rely on population estimates from other sources to enable the production
of victimization rates for people with disabilities.
People with developmental disabilities are four to 10 times more
likely to be victims of crime than other people are. (Sobsey,
D., Wells, D., Lucardie,R., and Mansell, S. 1995. Violence
and Disability: An Annotated Bibliography.
Baltimore, MD. Brookes Publishing.)
In response to a recent survey of women with physical disabilities,
56 percent reported abuse, a number consistent with other studies
of this nature. Of this group, 87 percent reported physical abuse;
66 percent reported sexual abuse; 35 percent were refused help
with a physical need; and 19 percent were prevented from using
an assistive device. (Wayne State University.
2004. Michigan Study on Women with
Physical Disabilities. Washington,
D.C.: National Institute of Justice, U.S. Department of Justice.)
In this same survey, 74 percent of the women reported abuse that
was chronic in nature and 55 percent reported multiple abuse situations
in their adult lives. The abuser was their male partner 80 percent
of the time. (Ibid.)
Of the women with physical disabilities reporting abuse, their
abusers were using drugs and/or alcohol 53 percent of the time. (Ibid.)
Only 33 percent of the abused women with physical disabilities
who were surveyed sought assistance to address the abuse, and from
this group, there were mixed reactions as to whether
the assistance had been a positive experience. (Ibid.)
In a five-year retrospective study of 4,340 child patients with
disabilities in a pediatric hospital, 68 percent were found to
be victims of sexual abuse and 32 percent were victims of physical
abuse. (Willging, J.P., Bower, C.M., and Cotton,
R.T. 1992. Physical Abuse of Children: A Retrospective Review
and an Otolaryngology Perspective. Archives
of Otolaryngology and Head and Neck Surgery 118(6):584-590.)
The National Rehabilitation Information Center estimates that
as many as 50 percent of patients who are long-term residents of
hospitals and specialized rehabilitation centers are there due
to crime-related injuries. In addition, it is estimated that at
least six million serious injuries occur each year due to crime,
resulting in either temporary or permanent disability. (Office
for Victims of Crime Bulletin. 1998. Working
with Victims of Crime with Disabilities.
Washington, D.C: U.S. Department of Justice.)
In a study of 946 women, 62 percent of women with and without
disabilities reported that they had experienced emotional, physical,
or sexual abuse. However, women with disabilities reported experiencing
their abuse for longer periods of time (3.9 vs. 2.5 years respectively).
In addition to the types of abuse experienced by the entire group,
women with disabilities specifically reported that their perpetrators
sometimes withheld needed orthotic equipment (e.g., wheelchairs,
braces), medications, transportation, or essential assistance with
personal tasks such as dressing or getting out of bed. (Young,
M.E., et al. 1997. Prevalence of Abuse of Women with Physical
Disabilities. Archives of
Physical Medicine and Rehabilitation Special Issue.
78 (12, Suppl. 5) S34-S38.) For more information visit, www.bcm.tmc.edu/crowd/national_study/national_study.html.
Sobsey and Doe estimate that more than half of abuse of people
with disabilities is generally perpetrated by family members and
peers with disabilities and that disability professionals (i.e.,
paid or unpaid caregivers, doctors, nurses) are generally believed
responsible for the other half. It is estimated that approximately
67 percent of perpetrators who abused individuals with severe cognitive
disabilities accessed them through their work in disability services. (Sobsey,
D., & Doe, T. 1991. Patterns of sexual abuse and assault. Journal
of Sexuality and Disability, 9(3):
243-259.)
Sixty-one percent of sexual assault survivors with disabilities
who received counseling services at SafePlace in Austin, Texas,
between 1996-2002, reported multiple perpetrators of violence.
Approximately 90 percent of the sexual violence perpetrators were
not strangers to their victims. (SafePlace.
2003. Stop the Violence, Break
the Silence. Austin, TX.)
In a national survey of domestic violence and rape-crisis agencies,
67 percent of the survey participants reported that their center
had served people with mental illness labels over the past year.
Despite the high incidence of violence against people with disabilities,
few participants reported that their center served people with
cognitive disabilities (seven percent), physical disabilities (six
percent), or who are blind, deaf or have hearing loss (one percent).
(Schwartz, M., Abramson, W., & Kamper,
H. 2004. A National Survey on the Accessibility of Domestic
Violence and Sexual Assault Services to Women with Disabilities. Unpublished
raw data. Austin, TX. SafePlace.)
Note: Given the small size/scope of some of these studies,
results cannot be extrapolated to the nation as a whole.
With funding from the Department of Justice (Office for Victims
of Crime), SafePlace's Disability Services ASAP (A Safety
Awareness Program), in Austin, Texas, is working with 10 victim
assistance organizations from across the country to enhance and
expand services for crime victims who have disabilities. The organizations
include: The Southern Arizona Center Against Sexual Assault, Tucson,
AZ; The Chadwick Center for Children & Families at Children's
Hospital and Health Center, San Diego, CA; Ability 1st, Tallahassee,
FL; Partnership Against Domestic Violence, Atlanta, GA; Carbondale
Illinois Police Department, Carbondale, IL; The Lafourche Parish
Sheriff's Office, Thidodaux, LA; Safe Passage, Northhampton,
MA; Rape Crisis Center of Central Massachusetts, Worcester, MA;
Ulster County Crime Victims Assistance Program, Kingston, NY; and
the Network of Victim Assistance, Doylestown, PA. SafePlace is
administering grant funding and providing expert training and technical
assistance to the 10 organizations to foster innovative practices,
principles and community partnerships for delivering accessible
services to crime victims with a wide range of disabilities. Each
of the 10 victim assistance organizations has conducted a community
needs assessment and developed a strategic plan to determine the
best way to address the identified gaps and barriers to victim
services for people with disabilities. Additionally, each organization
has developed a programmatic evaluation plan to identify performance
measures for determining progress and success and a sustainability
plan to ensure that activities continue beyond the grant period.
The organizations will continue to implement their strategic plan
during the second and third years of the project. This venture
takes the lessons and achievements of SafePlace's model Disability
Services program (begun in 1996) to communities across the country.
For more information about the Disability Services ASAP project,
visit www.austin-safeplace.org.
|
National Crime Victims' Rights
Week: Justice Isn't Served Until Crime Victims Are |
April 1016, 2005 |
|